Carrie Underwood is making a legendary homecoming to “American Idol”, and fans are already losing their minds. Almost two decades after her life-changing Season 4 win, Underwood is set to return to the iconic franchise—not as a contestant, but as a judge. Her debut on the panel alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan marks a full-circle moment that has viewers buzzing with excitement and nostalgia.
In a heartwarming promo, ABC highlighted Carrie’s journey, starting with her unforgettable audition and culminating in her victory that launched a chart-topping career. The video stirred an emotional response online, with one fan gushing, ““This gave me chills and made me want to cry. I always voted for Carrie, and now look at her!”” Another fan chimed in, ““That’s our girl! Welcome home, Carrie!””
The country superstar will reportedly earn $12 million for her first season as a judge—a figure modest compared to Katy Perry’s $25 million per season during her seven-year tenure. However, sources say Carrie didn’t need a Perry-sized paycheck to say yes, thanks to her deep connection to the “Idol” legacy. As an insider explained, ““She’s been part of the Idol family since its early days and has a vested interest in its success.””
Ryan Seacrest, who famously announced Carrie as the winner back in 2005, couldn’t contain his excitement about her return. Sharing a nostalgic throwback on social media, he wrote, ““It’s a full-circle moment to go from announcing you as the winner to welcoming you as a judge. Welcome home, @carrieunderwood!””
Carrie’s approach to judging promises a balance of honesty and compassion. She’s said she aims to provide constructive feedback with kindness, understanding the weight of the moment for aspiring contestants. ““People are sharing their dreams with you,”” she explained. ““You’re part of their story from that moment on.””
Underwood steps into the role following Perry’s departure, which insiders attribute to scheduling conflicts and her focus on her music career. Carrie, by contrast, is praised for her grounded approach and her humility. Her return is not just a win for the show—it’s a nostalgic triumph for longtime fans who’ve watched her journey from small-town hopeful to global superstar.
With Carrie joining the judges’ table, “American Idol” fans have more reason than ever to tune in. It’s not just a competition; it’s a reunion with a star who’s never forgotten her roots.
